The foundations of transformative private law in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.38140/aa.v57i1.9852Keywords:
transformative constitutionalism, private law, natural law, critical legal studiesAbstract
This article problematises a shallow understanding of "transformative private law" as being a simple merger of constitutional rights and private law. Instead, feeding into international discourse on transformative private law, it is argued that a South African iteration of the concept ought to be rooted in "transformative constitutionalism". Exploring the jurisprudential foundations of transformative constitutionalism, it becomes clear that we are not dealing with classical liberal constitutionalism. Instead, we are dealing with a type of constitutionalism committed to the legal traditions of natural law and critical legal studies that envisages a politicisation of law. Against that backdrop, it is argued that "private law" as an area traditionally thought of as being apolitical is ripe for transformative analysis and critique. However, the complicated effect of the coming together of transformative constitutionalism and private law is that the "private" in private law is weathered away. Is transformative private law then capable of existing? And if so, how?
References
Bartl M. 2020. The idea of transformative private law. Available at: https://transformativeprivatelaw.com/the-idea-of-transformative-private-law/ [accessed on 30 June 2025].
Bartl M. 2023. Towards transformative private law: research strategies. The Italian Law Journal 9(2): 413-423.
Beckers A, Eller KH and Kjaer PF. 2022. The transformative law of political economy in Europe. European Law Open 1(4): 749-759.
Bilchitz D, Metz T and Oyowe O. 2017. Jurisprudence in an African context. Cape Town: Oxford University Press.
Boonzaier L. 2024. Common-law avoidance. South African Law Journal 141(2): 213-256.
Botha H. 2004. Freedom and constraint in constitutional adjudication. South African Journal on Human Rights 20(2): 249-283.
Brickhill J and Van Leeve Y. 2015. Transformative constitutionalism – Guiding light or empty slogan? Acta Juridica 2015(1): 141-171.
Brickhill J, Hassim A, Bishop M and Ngcukaitobi T. 2024. Constitutionalism. In: Brickhill J, Hassim A, Bishop M and Ngcukaitobi T (eds). South African constitutional law. Cape Town: Juta.
Celikates R and Flynn J. 2023. Critical Theory (Frankfurt School). In: Zalta EN and Nodelman U (eds). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2023/entries/critical-theory/ [accessed on 20 June 2025].
Cockrell A. 1993. ‘Can you paradigm?’ – Another perspective on the public law/private law divide. Acta Juridica 1993(1): 227-247.
Council for Higher Education. 2018. The state of the provision of the Bachelor of Laws (LLB) qualification in South Africa. Available at: https://www.che.ac.za/publications/reports/state-provision-bachelor-laws-llb-qualification-south-africa [accessed on 30 June 2025].
Davies H and Holdcroft D. 1991. Jurisprudence: texts and commentary. London: Butterworths.
Davis D and Klare K. 2010. Transformative constitutionalism and the common and customary law. South African Journal on Human Rights 26(3): 403-509.
Froneman J. 2005. Legal reasoning and legal culture: our “vision” of law. Stellenbosch Law Review 16(1): 3-20.
Hesselink M. 2020. The idea of transformative private law: Some critical observations. Available at: https://transformativeprivatelaw.com/the-idea-of-transformative-private-law-some-critical-observations/ [accessed on 30 June 2025].
Heywood A. 2013. Politics. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Kjaer P. 2022. What is transformative law? European Law Open 1(4): 760-780.
Kjaer P (ed). 2020. The law of political economy: transformation in the function of law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Klare KE. 1998. Legal culture and transformative constitutionalism. South African Journal on Human Rights 14(1): 146-188.
Langa P. 2006. Transformative constitutionalism. Stellenbosch Law Review 17(3): 351-360.
Le Roux W and Van Marle K. 2004. Critical legal studies. In: Roederer C and Moellendorf D (eds). Jurisprudence. Cape Town: Juta.
LE ROUX WB. 2004. Natural law theories. In: Roederer C and Moelendorf D (eds). Jurisprudence. Cape Town: Juta.
Leiter B. 2010. Legal formalism and legal realism: what is the issue? Legal Theory 16(2): 111-133.
Mak C. 2020. Reflections on transformative private law. Available at: https://transformativeprivatelaw.com/reflections-on-transformative-private-law/ [accessed on 30 June 2025].
Meyerson D. 2013. Jurisprudence. Victoria: Oxford University Press.
Molaba T. 2025. The Concept of transformative constitutionalism in post-apartheid South Africa. Perspectives of Law and Public Administration 14(1): 119-217.
Moseneke D. 2002. The fourth Bram Fischer memorial lecture – Transformative adjudication. South African Journal on Human Rights 18(3): 309-319.
Pieterse M. 2005. What do we mean when we talk about transformative constitutionalism? SA Public Law 20(1): 155-166.
Roux T. 2009. Transformative constitutionalism and the best interpretation of the South African constitution: distinction without a difference? Stellenbosch Law Review 20(2): 258-285.
Sibanda S. 2011. Not purpose-made! Transformative constitutionalism, post-independence constitutionalism and the struggle to eradicate poverty. Stellenbosch Law Review 22(3): 482-500.
Stone M. 2004. Formalism. In: Coleman JL, Himma KE, Shapiro SJ (eds). The Oxford handbook of jurisprudence and philosophy of law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tushnet M. 1991. Critical legal studies: a political history. Yale Law Journal 100(5): 1515-1544.
UFS Private Law. 2015. International conference on transformative constitutionalism and private law: Call for papers. Bloemfontein: University of the Free State.
Van Blerk A. 1991. Critical legal studies in South Africa. South African Law Journal 113(1): 86-108.
Van den Berg Y. 2020. The transformative private law blog: an Introduction. Available at: https://transformativeprivatelaw.com/the-transformative-private-law-blog-an-introduction/ [accessed on 30 June 2025].
Van der Walt A. 2009. Property in the margins. Oxford: Hart Publishing.
Van der Walt J. 2000. Die toekoms van die onderskeid tussen die publiekreg en privaatreg in die lig van die horisontale werking van die grondwet (deel 1). Tydskrif vir die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 2000(3): 416-427.
Van der Walt J. 2003. Blixen’s difference: Horizontal application of fundamental rights and the resistance to neo-colonialism. Tydskrif vie die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg 2003(2): 311-331.
Van Marle K. 2009. Transformative constitutionalism as/and critique. Stellenbosch Law Review 20(2): 286-301.
Van Marle K. 2019. Hold onto critical jurisprudence. Law Democracy and Development 23(1): 202-218.
Van Staden M. 2021. Spontaneous order or central planning? A brief overview of the libertarian approach to law. Tydskrif vir Heedendaagse Romeins-Hollandse Reg 84(1): 53-67.
Van Zyl DH. 1979. Geskiedenis van die Romeins-Hollandse Reg. Durban: Butterworths.
Woolman S. 2015-2016. Understanding South Africa’s aspirational constitution as scaffolding. New York Law School Law Review 60(2): 283-295.
Zitzke E. 2015. Constitutional heedlessness and over-excitement in the common law of delict’s development. Constitutional Court Review 7: 259-290.
Zitzke E. 2023. Transformative legal history and the (re)classification of the South African law of delict. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal 2023(26): 1-31.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Emile Zitske
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
