Precarity, ungrievability, and thinking beyond the law: a framework for understanding the position of LGB individuals in South Africa
Keywords:South African Constitution, LGB rights, sexual violence, grievability, legislation
Drawing primarily on the work of Judith Butler and Drucilla Cornell, this paper aims to provide a theoretical framework for understanding the position of sexual minorities in South Africa. This will be done particularly in light of the violence, discrimination, and marginalisation that is experienced by, predominantly, black gay, lesbian, and bisexual individuals from poorer South African communities. In so doing, the paper also explores how the marginalisation of and violence against LGB individuals play an important role in national identity development and the upholding of a hetero-patriarchal social order. The goal is thus to create an understanding of why, despite legal and constitutional rights, LGB individuals continue to be marginalised, violated, and discriminated against in their everyday lived experiences, and further, why, because of this socio-symbolic positioning, the law cannot necessarily guarantee these rights or protections.
ActionAid. 2009. Hate crimes: The rise of corrective rape in South Africa. ActionAid. Available at: https://www.actionaid.org.uk/sites/default/.../correctiveraperep_final.pdf. [accessed on 31 March 2022].
ActionAid. n.d. Campaigning for LGBTQI rights in South Africa. ActionAid. Available at: https://www.actionaidusa.org/work/campaigning-lgbtqi-rights-south-africa/ [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Adams R. 2018. South Africa’s social contract: the Economic Freedom Fighters and the rise of a new constituent power? Acta Academica 50(3): 102-121.
Ahmed S. 2000. Strange encounters: embodied others in post-coloniality. New York: Routledge.
Ahmed S. 2005. The skin of the community: affect and boundary formation. In: Charter T and Ziarek EP (eds). Revolt, affect, collectivity: the unstable boundaries of Kristeva’s Polis. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Albertyn C. 2019. (In)equality and the South African Constitution. Development South Africa 36(6): 751-766.
Al Jazeera. 2021. EU takes legal action against Hungary, Poland over LGBTQ rights. AL Jazeera. 15 July. Available at: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/7/15/eu-takes-legal-action-against-hungary-poland-over-lgbtq-rights [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Baczynska G and Emmott R. 2021. Hungary rejects EU demand to ditch 'shameful' anti-LGBT law. Reuters. 7 July. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/a-disgrace-hungary-must-ditch-anti-lgbt-law-eu-executive-says-2021-07-07/ [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Brown R. 2012. Corrective rape in South Africa: a continual plight despite an international human rights response. Annual Survey of International and Comparative Law 18: 45-66.
Butler J. 2003. Violence, mourning, politics. Studies in Gender and Sexuality 4(1): 9-37.
Butler J. 2004. Precarious lives: the powers of violence and mourning. London and New York: Verso.
Butler J. 2009. Performativity, precarity, and sexual politics. AIBR: Revista de Antropología Iberoamericana 4(3): i-xiii.
Butler J. 2011. Remarks on ‘queer bonds’. GLQ 17(23): 381-387.
Butler J. 2012. Precarious life, vulnerability, and the ethics of cohabitation. Journal of Speculative Philosophy 26(2): 134-151.
Butler J. 2020. The force of non-violence. London and New York: Verso.
Christiansen E. 2016. Substantive equality and sexual orientation: twenty years of gay and lesbian rights adjudication under the South African Constitution. Cornell International Law Journal 49: 565-615.
Cock J. 2003. Engendering gay and lesbian rights: the equality clause in the South African Constitution. Women’s Studies International Forum 26(1): 35-45.
Cornell D. 1995. The imaginary domain: abortion, pornography, and sexual harassment. New York: Routledge.
De Greef K. 2019. The unfulfilled promise of LGBTQ rights in South Africa. The Atlantic. 2 July. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2019/07/southafrica-lgbtq-rights/593050/ [accessed on 31 March 2022].
De Sousa Santos B. 2017. The resilience of abyssal exclusions in our societies: toward a post-abyssal law. Tilburg Law Review 22: 237-258.
Du Toit HL. 2016. The South African Constitution as memory and promise: an exploration of its implications for sexual violence. Politikon: South African Journal of Political Studies 43(1): 31-51.
Guenther L. 2012. Resisting Agamben: the biopolitics of shame and humiliation. Philosophy and Social Criticism 38(1): 59-79.
Harrisberg K. 2021. LGBTQ+ South Africans resist ‘war on queerness’ as activists demand justice after killings. Global Citizen. 17 May. Available at: https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/fear-lgbt-south-africans-war-on-queerness/ [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Haynes J. 2020. Right-wing populism and religion in Europe and the USA. Religions 11(10): 490-508.
ILGA World. 2020. State-sponsored homophobia 2020: global legislation overview update. Geneva: ILGA.
Izugbara C, Bakare S, Sebany M, Ushie B, Wekesah F and Njagi J. 2020. Regional legal and policy instruments for addressing LGBT exclusion in Africa. Sexual and Reproductive Health Matter 28(1): 1-14.
Jones SG and Doxsee C. 2021. The escalating terrorism problem in the United States. Centre for Strategic and International Studies. 17 June. Available at: https://www.csis.org/analysis/escalating-terrorism-problem-united-states [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Judge M. 2018. Blackwashing homophobia: violence and the politics of sexuality, gender and race. Oxford and New York: Routledge.
Madlingozi T. 2017. Social justice in a time of neo-apartheid constitutionalism: critiquing the anti-black economy of recognition, incorporation and distribution. Stellenbosch Law Review 1: 123-147.
Mamdani M. 1996. Citizen and subject: contemporary Africa and the legacy of late colonialism. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Mamdani M 2001. Beyond settler and native as political identities: overcoming the political legacy of colonialism. Comparative Studies in Society and History 43(4): 651-664.
Muholi Z. 2004. Thinking through lesbian rape. Agenda: Empowering Women for Gender Equity 61 (Religion and Spirituality): 116-125.
Ramose M. 2007. In memoriam: sovereignty in the “new” South Africa. Griffith Law Review 16: 310-329.
Ratele K. 2013. Masculinities without tradition. Politikon: South African Journal of Political Studies 40(1): 133-156.
Simelane BC. 2021. Hate crimes bill — ‘the buck stops with parliament,’ says Department of Justice. The Daily Maverick. 2 June. Available at: https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2021-06-02-hate-crimes-bill-the-buck-stops-with-parliament-says-department-of-justice/ [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Smith D. 2010. South African minister describes lesbian photos as immoral. The Guardian. 2 March. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/mar/02/south-african-minister-lesbian-exhibition. [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Stacey R. 2003. ‘We the people’: the relationship between the South African Constitution and the ANC’s transformation policies. Politikon 30(2): 133-148.
The International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association. 2019. World’s 2019 Annual Report. Available at: https://ilga.org/downloads/ILGA_World_Annual_Report_2019.pdf. [accessed on 31 March 2022].
Thomas K, Masinjila M and Bere E. 2013. Political transition and sexual and gender-based violence in South Africa, Kenya, and Zimbabwe: a comparative analysis. Gender and Development 21(3): 519-532.
Visvanathan S. 2006. Nation. Theory, Culture and Society 23(2-3): 533-549.
Westman CS. 2019. ‘There’s no such thing as gay’: Black lesbians and nationhood in post-apartheid South Africa. PhD Thesis. Stellenbosch University. Available at: https://scholar.sun.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10019.1/107314/westman_nationhood_2019.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y [accessed on 15 February 2022].
Copyright (c) 2022 Claire Westman
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.